Comments on naijablog: Bollywood in Northern Nigeria

IMHO the censorship board and the A daidaita sahu ...

2009-01-30T14:07:00.000+01:00

IMHO the censorship board and the A daidaita sahu seem to say they object to the singing and dancing, and thats all they seem to talk about. -its not part of our culture, etc.

I don't think they really engage with film on any level above a very limited viewpoint that film should represent "real" hausa life.
At least that was what they kept saying to me about their objections.

They don't seem to be really bothered about the plotlines or characters of movies as reasons to ban them (at least thats not what they say), although I did ask one guy from ADDS if he saw a film about a powerful political figure who stole money from the people and had many girlfriends, and got away with it, should that film be banned? He said "yes", so they can't be that dedicated to "real life" in Kano. ;)

I think they just want film as a way of reinforcing traditional and islamic rules (what a coincidence that they are the ones who benefit from their reinforcement directly!)

It's indicative of a small clique of very mentally inflexible people who can't really understand concepts in art or filmmaking like plot, bathos, pathos, character, tone or even metaphore, who have been let loose with a big stick to hit people with, probably for some deeper political motive.

Hi Carmen, How are you? Longest time. Stopped by y...

2009-01-28T23:04:00.000+01:00

Hi Carmen,

How are you? Longest time. Stopped by your blog. Loved the interview with Habila. Also, I did not know about the Iyan-tama case. Thanks for sharing.

Hey Jeremy,Just noticed your stats, with so much t...

2009-01-28T22:53:00.000+01:00

Hey Jeremy,

Just noticed your stats, with so much traffic, why don't you monetize this blog? Between google adwords and flights to Naija etc... you could clean up!

Great questions, and Brian Larkin's research and a...

2009-01-28T17:48:00.000+01:00

Great questions, and Brian Larkin's research and analysis is brilliant. But I think the overwhelming focus on the influence of Bollywood themes/formats in Hausa films (which is obviously there--but critics here in Kano often say that the Indian influence is ALL that is there--that there is no originality in the Hausa films) risks overlooking ways in which filmmakers are actually reflecting on contemporary Hausa society. More recent Hausa films are of course inflenced by more recent Indian films, with their more "Westernized themes and influences." That's a fair enough statement to make. But they are also reflecting (sometimes in a stylized fashion) the actual lives of young people living in Northern Nigeria right here and right now. This is a somewhat controversial point to make, as critics I have spoken to often say that the films are reflecting ONLY foreign cultural imperialism. But as filmmakers I have spoken to have said "culture changes." I can't tell you how many times filmmakers have also told me that "this is a true story." "This really happened." "This happened to my neighbor." So, yes, changes in Bollywood have changed Hausa films. But so have changes in Kano, in Nigeria, in NileSat, in MTV, etc. etc. etc.